Ray's Replies: Is Kelly 'looking dumb' by waiting on Vick?

Ray's Replies: Is Kelly 'looking dumb' by waiting on Vick?
February 8, 2013, 9:00 am
Share This Post

Sports Movies Night

You can join Ray Didinger of CSNPhilly.com and Glen Macnow of WIP for a
sports movies night at the Eagles Nova Care Complex on Wednesday, February
13th with the proceeds going to charity.

Didinger and Macnow will host an evening that features classic scenes from
some of the best sports movies of all-time, including Rocky, Hoosiers, The
Natural, Million Dollar Baby and others. Didinger and Macnow, who authored
"The Ultimate Book of Sports Movies" will share little-known details about
the making of these films and also answer questions from the audience.

Tickets cost $50 and each person who attends will receive a gift copy of
"The Ultimate Book of Sports Movies," a $20 value. Didinger and Macnow will
sign each book.

Doors open at 6 p.m. and the program starts at 6:30. It will be held in the
auditorium at the NovaCare Complex. Light snacks will be provided following
the program in the Eagles' cafeteria.

Money raised will benefit the Eagles Youth Partnership and City Year Greater
Philadelphia. It will help fund the Eagles Eye Mobile and Eagles Book Mobile
as well as other EYP outreach programs. The event is part of the Eagles
Radiothon, an annual event on WIP Sportsradio.

Tickets can be obtained by contacting the Eagles Youth Partnership or WIP or
going to the following link:

http://www.philadelphiaeagles.com/community/eagles-youth-partnership/fun...

Q. Some reporters keep repeating the Eagles have nothing to lose by keeping Mike Vick and not making a decision until the last possible minute. I totally disagree. Chip Kelly is a brand new coach so everyone is watching every move he makes to see if he knows what he is doing. This is his first and most important player personnel decision in the NFL.

Logically, a new coach would immediately dump an old, declining quarterback like Vick. He has failed miserably the past three years. It is a no-brainer. Kelly is looking dumb and indecisive and showing a lack of strong leadership by being wishy-washy on this obvious but important decision.

I think a poor perception of Kelly is more harmful than possibly a seventh-round draft pick they could get in a trade (for Vick).

-Domenic Z.


A. I think you are overreacting, Domenic. I don’t think the rest of the NFL will judge Kelly on this decision nor should they. This is just one of many decisions the new coach has to make as he begins cleaning up the mess he inherited from Andy Reid. The question of whether he knows what he is doing won’t be answered in this offseason. It will take time.

I don’t have a problem with Kelly keeping Vick on the roster for now. The Eagles don’t have to pay Vick the $3 million until March, so they have time to weigh their options and that’s what they are doing. It doesn’t mean Kelly is dumb or indecisive. It has nothing to do with leadership. He is just doing his homework and taking his time. That’s fine.

I don’t know what Kelly ultimately plans to do, but if it were up to me, I would cut ties with Vick at some point within the next month. In that regard, Domenic, we agree.

Even if Vick agreed to accept a pay cut, it wouldn’t make sense for the Eagles to keep him around. It’s time to move on, turn the page, pick any cliché you like. Vick will find a QB job for next season, but it should not be here.

Some see Vick as a fit for Kelly’s offense. I don’t. For one thing, he never has run anything like Kelly’s option, which means he would be trying to learn a new offense. The reads, the ball-handling and timing are totally different. Asking a soon-to-be 33-year-old quarterback, who isn’t always the best pupil, to make that kind of transition does not make sense.

Those who try to project Vick in this offense do so because they still think of him as a running threat. He’s not anymore. He hasn’t just lost a step, he has lost more than that and in the NFL that’s the difference between explosive and ordinary. The option is a different kind of running anyway. It is not scrambling; it is assignment running, reading on the move and reacting. Again, it would be new to Vick.

Kelly has said he can’t play with quarterbacks who take bad sacks and quarterbacks who turn the ball over. Those are the things that characterized Vick’s play the past two seasons. If Kelly is studying the tape, he will see ample evidence of that.

Also, in the option, the quarterback gets hit a lot. He doesn’t have the rules to protect him in the same way they protect a drop-back passer. So how does a player as injury-prone as Vick figure in that equation? Simply put, he doesn’t.

In my opinion, keeping Vick around would be a waste of time. Even if you think he can run this offense, could you foresee him running it two years from now? He’ll be 34 then with an even thicker medical file. There’s no point.

Vick would be, at best, a one-year stop gap and Kelly would have to start over with another quarterback the following year. He would be better off trying to develop that quarterback now. Keeping Vick for another year will only slow down the process.