Why Vanek to the Flyers wouldn't have worked

vanekusa.jpg

Why Vanek to the Flyers wouldn't have worked

It didn’t take long to wake up and perform some Monday-morning general managing following the glacier-melting hockey headline that the Sabres had traded highly skilled winger Thomas Vanek. In exchange, the Islanders sent a first-round pick, a second-round pick and 30-year-old forward Matt Moulson packing to Buffalo.

After absorbing the news for a few days, you may have come to the realization that the Flyers could have easily acquired what the Islanders had lured away from the Sabres. Even if general manager Paul Holmgren had genuine interest in Vanek’s services, a blockbuster wouldn’t have made sense, and here’s why:

1. Are the Flyers even a playoff team?
Anytime you mortgage a portion of your future for a superstar-caliber player like Vanek, you better have a definitive "yes" answer to this question. Right now, the Flyers can’t honestly say that. They may feel like one with the players they’ve assembled, but they’re in a transitional period after firing Peter Laviolette three games into the season. If the Flyers were winning in spite of their lack of scoring, then a Vanek deal would have been feasible.

2. The salary cap
Unfortunately for the Flyers and a handful of other NHL teams, whatever you import in cap dollars you also have to export. Vanek comes attached with a $7.1 million cap hit, so essentially the Flyers would have had to ship that same cap amount to Buffalo. Since the Sabres have disclosed their intentions of rebuilding, GM Darcy Regier is looking to trim his payroll, not add to it. Acquiring Moulson saves the Sabres roughly $2.5 million. Certainly, the Flyers could have packaged players to cover Vanek’s cap hit, but they still would have to unload draft picks, and that’s too lopsided a trade even for the Flyers.

3. Vanek is an impending UFA
Let’s say the Sabres requested a young player like Sean Couturier or Brayden Schenn in return. Is it worth moving one of these guys for just one season of Vanek, who will command a free-agent price tag in the $8 million range at the end of the season? Not at all.

4. Flyers don't need another long-term contract
Assume Holmgren wouldn't have negotiated a trade unless Vanek agreed to stay in Philadelphia long-term. It’s still not worth it. The Flyers already have 15 players on next season’s payroll totaling $56 million (current cap is $64 million), and that’s without a goaltender under contract. Squeezing Vanek into the Flyers' 2014-15 cap would have been nearly impossible, even for one of those contortionists who perform at halftime of an NBA game.    

5. The core has to perform
If the Flyers' current roster can’t consistently score goals, there’s nothing Vanek could have done to remedy that problem either. Claude Giroux, Scott Hartnell, Jakub Voracek and other cast members have to start elevating their games and, more importantly, scoring goals. Otherwise, it doesn’t matter who you bring in from the outside.

Best of NHL: Bryan Rust notches hat trick as Pens score 8 in win

Best of NHL: Bryan Rust notches hat trick as Pens score 8 in win

PITTSBURGH -- Bryan Rust had his first career hat trick, Sidney Crosby added his NHL-leading 17th goal and the Pittsburgh Penguins raced by the Ottawa Senators 8-5 on Monday night.

Evgeni Malkin and Phil Kessel each had a goal and two assists for Pittsburgh, and Matt Cullen and Justin Schultz also scored. The Penguins poured in six goals over the final 32 minutes after spotting the Senators a 4-2 lead. Matt Murray made 17 saves after coming in for an ineffective Marc-Andre Fleury in the second period.

Pittsburgh has won three straight overall and improved to 7-0-2 in its last nine against the Senators.

Matt Stone had a goal and two assists for Ottawa. Erik Karlsson, Mike Hoffman, Mark Stone and Dion Phaneuf also scored for Ottawa, which lost in regulation for just the second time in its last eight games (see full recap).

Capitals rally late for OT win over Sabres
WASHINGTON -- Marcus Johansson scored the tying goal late in the third period and got the winner midway through overtime to lift the Washington Capitals to a 3-2 victory over the Buffalo Sabres on Monday night.

The goals were Johansson's third and fourth in his last five games. He has 11 for the season.

Jay Beagle added the Capitals' first even-strength goal in three games, as Washington snapped a three-game losing skid. Braden Holtby made 31 saves in the victory, the Capitals second over the Sabres in an 11-day stretch.

Kyle Okposo scored his team-leading eighth goal of the season to give the Sabres the lead in the second period. Zemgus Girgensons also scored early for Buffalo, and Robin Lehner made 30 stops for the visitors (see full recap).

Blue Jackets sweep series from Coyotes
COLUMBUS, Ohio -- Sam Gagner had two goals and two assists to help the Columbus Blue Jackets beat the Arizona Coyotes for the second time in three days, 4-1 on Monday night.

Nick Foligno and Zach Werensky also scored for the Blue Jackets, who won for the fourth straight time and ninth of their last 12. Columbus picked up its 500th win in franchise history in sweeping the two-game season series with the Coyotes.

Sergei Bobrovsky stopped 17 shots for Columbus.

Arizona backup goaltender Louis Domingue had 30 saves, two days after the Blue Jackets hammered starter Mike Smith with a franchise-record 60 shots in a 3-2 shootout victory in Phoenix.

Arizona struck first 9:28 into the game when Alex Goligoski fed a pass on a power play to Tobias Reider, who slammed it past Bobrovsky's glove side from between the circles (see full recap).

Matt Read out approximately a month; Flyers recall Taylor Leier, send down Scott Laughton

Matt Read out approximately a month; Flyers recall Taylor Leier, send down Scott Laughton

Updated: 7 p.m.

Flyers winger Matt Read will miss approximately a month with an upper-body injury suffered in Sunday's 4-2 win over the Predators when he was checked by Filip Forsberg. Sources tell CSNPhilly.com's Tim Panaccio the injury is an oblique muscle pull in Read's upper torso.

The 30-year-old has six goals and four assists for 10 points through 27 games. Five of those goals came in the Flyers' first five games.

To replace Read's roster spot, the Flyers recalled Taylor Leier and sent Scott Laughton to AHL affiliate Lehigh Valley. That likely means penalty-kill specialist Boyd Gordon (back), who is eligible to come off long-term injury reserve, will be activated.

Leier, 22, has been playing well with the Phantoms, posting six goals and 14 assists in 22 games (see Future Flyers Report). This is Leier's second stint of the season with the Flyers, albeit his first was short — one game on Oct. 25 in which he was a healthy scratch. He made his NHL debut last season and played six games.

Laughton was a healthy scratch the past five games.

If for some reason Gordon is not activated, the Flyers can call up another forward from Lehigh Valley. Jordan Weal is tied for second in the AHL with 24 points (nine goals, 15 assists) in 20 games, while veteran winger Colin McDonald is an experienced, bottom-six option.