Phillies Stay or Go: Antonio Bastardo

bastardo-usa.jpg

Phillies Stay or Go: Antonio Bastardo

The Phillies' first losing season since 2002 is sure to bring wholesale changes in the offseason. But who should stay and who should go? Over the next two weeks, we're asking that very question and putting players under the microscope.

Wednesday, we examined Kevin Frandsen (see story), and today we take a look at a bullpen arm that let the team down in 2013:

Antonio Bastardo
Position: Left-handed relief pitcher
Status: Arbitration eligible; completed a one-year, $1.4 million deal in 2013

Signature game of 2013
Bastardo saved two games in 2013, but they were nothing special. Bastardo worked 10 games with no rest and didn’t bounce back too great, either. However, give Bastardo a day or two between outings and he was virtually unhittable. Opponents went 19 for 89 against the lefty when he worked with one or two days of rest, with a 2.10 ERA in 26 games.

Season as a whole
The numbers were not terrible — 3-2, two saves, 2.32 ERA, 47 strikeouts in 42 2/3 innings — but Bastardo’s season will be remembered for one event: the 50-game suspension for his role in baseball’s Biogenesis scandal. The suspension snuck up on the Phillies and left general manager Ruben Amaro Jr. and manager Charlie Manuel scrambling when the announcement came. If Bastardo knew something was coming, he didn’t clue in the Phillies or his teammates.

Otherwise, Bastardo was more efficient and threw more strikes than at any point in his career. He threw nearly 70 percent of his first pitches for strikes. He also allowed just two out of 15 inherited runners to score and was on a streak in which he did not allow a run in nine of 10 games before being suspended.

Stay or go
Typically, a reliever on pace to appear in 60-plus games for the third straight season is the type of pitcher a team needs and wants. A 28-year-old left-hander with that resume is even better. Bastardo is young and experienced and still moving into his prime.

But he really let the Phillies down over the last stretch of the season. Will he be dependable in the future? Carlos Ruiz, Freddy Galvis and Kevin Frandsen have served suspensions and come back to be model teammates. There is nothing to suggest that Bastardo will be a problem in the future, and for a bargain salary, he might be worth the risk.

What they're saying ...
“I talked with him the night before, and he said there may be something that goes on here. That was the only real heads-up I had. I don’t think the player has to tell us anything. He mentioned to me that something might be going on Sunday ... so I had an idea that something might be going on.”
--Ruben Amaro Jr. on Bastardo’s suspension, Aug. 5

“I was totally surprised. It caught me off guard. He plays a big role in our bullpen, but at the same time I go along with our organization. There’s rules and guidelines MLB has, and I think you have to abide by those. We’ll see where he is velocity-wise and command-wise in spring training, and he’ll probably get more innings than he usually gets. That will tell more about him.”
--Charlie Manuel on Bastardo’s suspension, Aug. 5

End could be near for Jimmy Rollins, who's unlikely to make Giants' roster

End could be near for Jimmy Rollins, who's unlikely to make Giants' roster

The long-expected homecoming for Jimmy Rollins didn't go as planned.

Rollins, now 38, is unlikely to make the San Francisco Giants' opening-day roster.

"We've talked to Jimmy and he knows the scenario and the situation," manager Bruce Bochy told reporters earlier this week. "We're just waiting to hear back from him."

J-Roll was hoping to catch on with the Giants as a utility infielder. San Francisco already has an everyday shortstop in Brandon Crawford, so Rollins' role would have been to back him up, play a little second base and perhaps some third base. 

But Rollins hit just .125 this spring and fell clearly behind fellow veteran Aaron Hill, who is three years younger and at this point simply a better hitter.

Is this the end for J-Roll? If it is, he'll finish with a .264/.324/.418 batting line in over 10,000 plate appearances, 2,455 hits, 511 doubles, 231 homers and 470 steals.

Rollins is one of just four players ever with that many career doubles and steals. The others are Barry Bonds, Ty Cobb and Paul Molitor.

While some players have precipitous drop-offs that lead to retirement -- forced or unforced -- Rollins' decline has been more gradual. His batting average has dipped in each of the last four seasons, from .252 in 2013 to .243 to .224 to .221 last season. 

Rollins latched on with the White Sox last spring and was their opening-day shortstop, but he was released on June 15 as Chicago made room for top prospect Tim Anderson.

Rollins, who played 15 seasons with the Phillies, is the franchise leader in at-bats, hits and doubles. He's second in steals, third in triples and runs scored, ninth in homers and eighth in RBIs.

He also won an MVP, a World Series, four Gold Gloves and made three All-Star teams.

Enough to make the Hall of Fame? That's obviously subjective, but for as much as he did for the Phillies and for how much he impacted the game for more than a decade, Rollins' rate stats -- namely the .251/.317/.395 batting line he posted from 2008-16 -- could keep him out of Cooperstown, even though some of his counting stats are more impressive than Barry Larkin's.

Phillies finalize bullpen; final two bench jobs to be announced later today

Phillies finalize bullpen; final two bench jobs to be announced later today

CLEARWATER, Fla. -- The Phillies finalized their bullpen Thursday morning and will complete the rest of their roster later in the day, manager Pete Mackanin said.

Lefties Adam Morgan and Joely Rodriguez were named to the final two spots in the bullpen after veteran Luis Garcia was optioned to Triple A.

The final two spots on the roster are both bench jobs. Brock Stassi, Daniel Nava and Jesmuel Valentin are the final candidates.

"We're going to pick two out of three and we'll know by the end of the game," Mackanin said before the Phillies were to play the Yankees in a 1 p.m. game.

There are indications that Stassi will make the roster, leaving the final spot down to Nava and Valentin. Nava is a first baseman/outfielder. Valentin, 22, is a second baseman by trade. If he doesn't make the club, he will play every day at Triple A.

Andres Blanco, Aaron Altherr and rookie catcher Andrew Knapp are already set on the bench.

Garcia was sent to the minors one day after pitching poorly against the Detroit Tigers in Lakeland. He was tagged for five hits and two runs in two innings of work. One of the hits was a double. Garcia needed 45 pitches to get through the two innings. He did not walk a batter and struck out three.

Garcia will likely close at Triple A.

"He developed a splitter over the course of spring training and we want him to go down and work on it," Mackanin said. "It could be a real good pitch for him in the future."

As far as bullpen roles, Morgan will work as a long man while Rodriguez will be more of a situational lefty. Jeanmar Gomez, Hector Neris, Edubray Ramos, Joaquin Benoit and Pat Neshek round out the bullpen.

Gomez will open the season as the closer. He saved 37 games last season but lost the job in September.

"I'm going to go with Gomez," Mackanin said. "He's going to get every opportunity to do the job. If he doesn't, we're going to take a look at it."